01 / 08
Grange
Claims line, open around the clock
1-800-422-0550- Billing
- 1-800-422-0550
- Online
- Grange website
Then call us on (937) 610-0088 so we can follow your claim.
Independent insurance · Sunbury, OH
Otto & Associates, independent insurance agents in Sunbury, Ohio. Appreciated, not tolerated.
Otto & Associates is a family-run independent insurance agency in Sunbury, Ohio. We compare eight companies for your home, car and business, and we stay with you when you have a claim.
- Independent agents
- Veteran owned
- Phone, video or in person
Closed now, opens Monday at 9:30 am 8 companies compared
- Homes
- Cars
- Boats
- Motorcycles
- Campers
- Rentals
- Small businesses
- Umbrella
- Contractors
- Condos
02Our companies
We shop 8 trusted companies so you don’t have to.
03What we cover
One agency for the whole family’s insurance.
Home, car, the boat, the business and everything in between. Open a line to see what fits, or hover to preview it.
Home and property Your home is probably your biggest asset
No two homes or owners are alike, so we quote several companies and find the policy that puts you back where you were after a loss, at a price that suits you.
- Homeowners
- Renters
- Condominium
- Landlord packages for rentals
- Vacant property
Auto When there is an accident, we stay on it
We do not just hand you to a claims adjuster. Whatever your driving record, we find the right company and help until the claim is resolved.
- Preferred drivers
- Standard drivers
- Non-standard and high-risk drivers
- SR22 bonds
Toys Protect the things you worked hard for
Boats, motorcycles, campers and ATVs need their own cover. We work with companies that specialise in them.
- Boats
- Motorcycles
- Travel trailers and motorhomes
- ATVs and other recreational vehicles
Umbrella Extra protection if you are ever sued
An umbrella policy pays for court costs and counsel, and adds liability limits above your home and auto policies. It costs little for what it covers.
- Higher liability limits
- Court costs and legal counsel
- Sits above home, auto and toys
Business Coverage for every stage of your business
A family firm with many employees or a one-person start-up: tell us what you do and we will find the coverage that fits.
- Business package policies
- Key person policies
- Business auto
- Contractor packages
04A free quote
Get a quote worth reading.
Tell us what you would like covered. We compare our companies and come back with real options, in plain English.
- 01You tell us what to quote. About a minute of your time.
- 02We shop our companies. Coverage and price, side by side.
- 03We call you when you’re ready. You choose. No pressure, ever.
Rather talk it through? Call (937) 610-0088.
05Claims
Had an accident or a loss?
Call your company’s claims line first, any hour. Then call us and we will help you through it.
- 01Make sure everyone is safeCall 911 if anyone is hurt.
- 02Call your companyNumbers below, open around the clock.
- 03Call usWe follow the claim until it is settled.
Find your company
No company by that name. Call us on (937) 610-0088 and we will find the right number.
01 / 08
02 / 08
Progressive
Claims line, open around the clock
1-800-776-4737- Billing
- 1-877-776-2436
- Online
- Progressive website
Then call us on (937) 610-0088 so we can follow your claim.
03 / 08
Encompass
Claims line, open around the clock
1-800-588-7400- Billing
- 1-866-430-2916
- Online
- Encompass website
Then call us on (937) 610-0088 so we can follow your claim.
04 / 08
MAPFRE
Claims line, open around the clock
1-877-224-5677- Billing
- 1-800-222-2114
- Online
- MAPFRE website
Then call us on (937) 610-0088 so we can follow your claim.
05 / 08
Foremost
Claims line, open around the clock
1-800-527-3905- Billing
- 1-800-532-4221
- Online
- Foremost website
Then call us on (937) 610-0088 so we can follow your claim.
06 / 08
Trexis
Claims line, open around the clock
1-877-584-7466- Billing
- 1-877-384-7466
- Online
- Trexis website
Then call us on (937) 610-0088 so we can follow your claim.
07 / 08
Commonwealth
Claims line, open around the clock
1-877-603-1310- Billing
- 1-877-603-1310
- Online
- Commonwealth website
Then call us on (937) 610-0088 so we can follow your claim.
08 / 08
National General
Claims line, open around the clock
1-800-468-3466- Billing
- 1-800-462-2123
- Online
- National General website
Then call us on (937) 610-0088 so we can follow your claim.
01 / 08
Turn the wheel, or pick a company from the list.
06Paperwork, quickly
Need a document today?
Ask online and Andi will send it during office hours. Drag or scroll to browse the shelf.
- Proof of insurance card For your glovebox, the BMV or a traffic stop Request it
- Declarations page A summary of what your policy covers Request it
- Certificate of insurance For contracts, landlords and job sites Request it
- Verification of insurance Proof for a lender, dealer or employer Request it
- Something else? Policy changes, payments, adding a driver or a vehicle. Just ask. Send a request
07Our family
A family agency, since 1998.
In 1998 Glenn answered a newspaper ad and found himself driving all over Ohio selling only life and health insurance, while clients kept asking if he did their cars and homes too.
Eight years as American Family agents followed, with Andi beside him from 2000, earning a J.D. Power customer service award along the way. Then they went independent, so they could choose the companies, choose how clients are treated, and say yes to almost anyone who calls.
Today they work from home in Sunbury and meet clients by phone, video or appointment.
— Glenn and Andi Otto
Meet your agents
Two people, one phone number
Ask for Andi by name
Founder
Andi Otto
Grew up in Tucson, Arizona, and served in the U.S. Air Force. Before insurance she ran offices and managed materials, which is why your paperwork gets done.
Book time with Andi
Ask for Glenn by name
Co-founder
Glenn Otto
Grew up in Beavercreek, Ohio, and served in the U.S. Army. Years in construction, auto repair and roofing mean he knows a claim from your side of it.
Book time with Glenn- 28
- years helping Ohio families
- 8
- companies quoted side by side
- 2
- veterans: U.S. Army and U.S. Air Force
- 1
- J.D. Power customer service award
09Questions
Questions we hear most
Something else on your mind? Call (937) 610-0088 or send us a note.
What does an independent agency do differently?
We are not tied to one insurance company. We quote your home, car or business with the companies we represent and show you the options side by side, so you choose the coverage and the price, and you understand what you are buying.
Can I meet with you outside office hours?
Yes. The office is open 9:30 to 5:00 Monday to Friday, and we see clients in the evening and at weekends by appointment. Book a time online or call us.
How do I get my proof of insurance card?
Send a request from the contact page and choose Proof of insurance card. The same form handles declarations pages, certificates of insurance and verification letters.
Who do I call when I have a claim?
Call your insurance company's claims line first; the numbers for every company we represent are on our home page. Then call us, and we will help you through it.
Can you insure a driver who needs an SR22?
Yes. We place preferred, standard and non-standard auto policies, and we file SR22 bonds for drivers who need one.
Do you insure small businesses?
Yes. We write business package policies, key person policies, business auto and contractor packages, for one-person shops and established family firms alike.
10Talk to us
A real person answers.
Office(937) 610-0088 Cell(937) 545-61486650 Kilbourne Rd., Sunbury, OH 43074. Visits by appointment.
Phone Video In person
Hours
Closed now, opens Monday at 9:30 am
- Monday9:30 am to 5:00 pm
- Tuesday9:30 am to 5:00 pm
- Wednesday9:30 am to 5:00 pm
- Thursday9:30 am to 5:00 pm
- Friday9:30 am to 5:00 pm
- Saturdayby appointment
- Sundayby appointment